Interesting comments from the former UK prime minister:
Tony Blair | Project Syndicate | 10th June 2013
"The problematic strain within Islam is not the province of a few extremists. It has at its heart a view of religion – and of the relationship between religion and politics – that is not compatible with pluralistic, liberal, open-minded societies. At the extreme end of the spectrum are terrorists, but the worldview goes deeper and wider than it is comfortable for us to admit. So, by and large, we don’t admit it... The better idea is a modern view of religion and its place in society and politics – a model based on respect and equality among people of different faiths. Religion may have a voice in the political system, but it must not govern it."
The rise of Islam has given liberalism (on the left and the right) a difficult choice:
- Keep up the pretense of religious neutrality. Which was easier to do the naive 1990's, when more people were apt to declare that "all religions are equally true". This became more difficult after 9-11, however, as Westerners began employing distinctions like "true Islam" (e.g. true Islam as opposed to false Islam? I thought all religions were equally true?).
- Drop the pretense of neutrality, and let liberal values judge religion. Political theory in this case claims for itself a higher authority than religion (or at least some religions), which seems to make logical sense only if political theory knows in advance which religious claims are false. This is a self-confident liberalism come full bloom. This is what Blair is saying.
A tough choice to be sure. But what choice is there that is politically effective and coherent?